Agave & Rye New Albany Menu

If you're in the New Albany area and craving a memorable dining experience, Agave & Rye New Albany Menu is definitely worth checking out. Located at 324 E Main St, New Albany, IN, this spot offers a mix of delicious tacos, vibrant cocktails, and a relaxed atmosphere perfect for a night out with friends or a casual dinner date. Whether you're in the mood for something spicy, savory, or a bit on the adventurous side, the menu here has something to satisfy all tastes. Their carefully crafted dishes feature fresh ingredients and bold flavors, designed to surprise and delight your taste buds. And with a great drink menu to pair, it’s easy to spend hours enjoying the laid-back vibe. You'll want to explore everything this place has to offer, from its creative taco combinations to its mouthwatering sides.

Combos

Buzz Box
Two of our Epic Tacos served with a half order of Chips and Salsa. Sub Guacamole for $2.00
US$19.20
Taco Flight (3)
Your choice of 3 delicious Flight Sized Tacos.
US$16.90

Chips & Dips

Pick 3
Choose Any 3 of Our House-Made from Scratch Dips
US$22.55
EPIC Size Pick 3 Dips
US$39.55
Chips & Chunky Salsa
House-Made from Scratch Tortilla Chips & Chunky Salsa (V | GF | VG)
US$6.25
Chips & EPIC Size Chunky Salsa
US$13.60
Chips & Ghost Pepper Salsa
US$6.80
Chips & EPIC Size Ghost Pepper Salsa
US$14.70
Chips & Salsa Roja
House-Made from Scratch Tortilla Chips & Salsa Roja (V | GF | VG)
US$6.25
Chips & EPIC Sized Salsa Roja
( V | GF )
US$13.60
Chips & Mango Pico
US$8.50
Chips & EPIC Size Mango Pico
US$14.70
Chips & Pico
US$6.25
Chips & EPIC Size Pico
US$13.60
Chips & Queso
House-Made from Scratch Tortilla Chips & Queso (V | GF)
US$11.25
Chips & EPIC Size Queso
Epic-Sized House Queso, Tortillas
US$20.35
Chips & Dirty Queso
US$13.60
Chips & Epic Size Dirty Queso
Queso + Andouille (GF)
US$22.60
Chips & Guacamole
House-Made from Scratch Tortilla Chips & Guacamole (V | GF)
US$12.45
Chips & EPIC Size Guacamole
EPIC Size House-Made from Scratch Tortilla Chips & Guacamole (V | GF)
US$21.50
Chips & Pimento Cheese
US$9.05
Chips & EPIC Size Pimento Cheese
Served with Crispy Soft Flour Tortillas
US$15.85

Munchies

Crispy Brussels Sprouts
Dijon Aioli, Sliced Almonds, Cotija Cheese (V | GF)
US$14.70
Quesabirria Irish Nachos
Slow Roasted Birria (beef), Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Queso, Mozzarella Cheese, Crispy French Fries, Cowboy Candy, Tobacco Onions
US$15.55
Sticky Cauliflower Bites
Sesame & Ginger Sauce, Crispy Wontons, Cilantro (V)
US$13.60
Mac N Cheese Donuts
Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Habanero Maple Dipping Sauce
US$13.60
Carne Asada Eggrolls (2)
House Carne Asada, A&R Teriyaki Sauce, A&R Spicy Chili & BBQ Jam, Baby Corn, Water Chestnuts, Cilantro, Green Onion, Carrots, Red Bell Pepper, Ramen Noodles
US$16.95
Carne Asada Eggroll (1)
House Carne Asada, A&R Teriyaki Sauce, A&R Spicy Chili & BBQ Jam, Baby Corn, Water Chestnuts, Cilantro, Green Onion, Carrots, Red Bell Pepper, Ramen Noodles
US$9.05
Shrimp Rangoon Bites
Diced Shrimp, Cheese & Cowboy Candy Filling, Sweet Chili Sauce, Spicy Crispy Carrots
US$14.70
OG Corn Fritters
Serrano Aioli
US$7.95
Elote
Cotija Cheese, Serrano Aioli, Tajin, Cilantro, Lime (cut from cob) (v | GF)
US$10.20
Crispy Elote Deviled Eggs
Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Cilantro
US$13.60
Southern Tater Tots
House Made Sea Salt Tater Tots, Pimento Cheese, Sweet and Spicy Bacon
US$15.85

EPIC Sides

Mexican Rice
(V | GF | VG)
US$6.80
Mac N Cheese
(V)
US$6.80
Egg Fried Rice
US$6.80
Pineapple Slaw
US$6.80
French Fry Duo
Waffle and Stick French Fries with Cotija, Cilantro, and Comeback Sauce (V | GF)
US$7.35
Side Of Tater Tots
US$8.20
BBQ Bacon Beans
US$6.80

EPIC Sized Tacos

The Swipe Right
Herbed Chicken, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Aged White Cheddar, Salsa, Sour Cream (GF) *If Gluten Free (GF) is listed with the EPIC Taco, it MUST be ordered WITHOUT the Flour Shell
US$10.15
The Crown Jewel
Butter & Garlic Lobster, Shiitake Mushrooms, Mac N Cheese, Truffle Oil & Shavings, Shaved Green Onions
US$15.80
The Alderman
Carne Asada Steak, Street Corn Salad, Cotija Cheese, Spicy Chile de Arbol Salsa (GF) *If Gluten Free (GF) is listed with the EPIC Taco, it MUST be ordered WITHOUT the Flour Shell
US$10.15
The Rooster
Crispy Chicken, Mac N Cheese, Nashville Hot Sauce, Sweet Pickles
US$9.35
The Bang Bang
Crispy Cauliflower, Corn Fritters, Queso, Spicy Crispy Carrots (V)
US$9.65
The Big Thumper
Peppercorn Kangaroo, Mac N Cheese Donuts, Roasted Corn, Sweet & Spicy Bacon Crumble, Green Onion, Habanero Maple Syrup, Queso Love Cushion,
US$15.80
The Bomb
Carne Asada Steak, Chopped Bourbon- Poached Shrimp, Mac N Cheese, A&R Spicy Chili & BBQ Jam, Tobacco Onions
US$15.30
The Plain Jane
Seasoned Ground Beef, Shredded Lettuce, Aged White Cheddar, Diced Tomato, Sour Cream (GF) *If Gluten Free (GF) is listed with the EPIC Taco, it MUST be ordered WITHOUT the Flour Shell
US$7.90
The Sugar Daddy Of The Plain Jane
Melted Aged White Cheddar between grilled Flour Tortilla and Consommé-Dipped Corn Tortilla, Seasoned Ground Beef, Queso, Lettuce, Sour Cream, Salsa, White Cheddar
US$9.65
The Filthy Fajita
Carne Asada Steak, Sautéed Mushrooms, Caramelized Onions, Red Peppers, Mexican Rice, Chipotle Crema, Queso
US$10.15
The Happy Pappy
Pork Carnitas, Mexican Rice, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Aged White Cheddar, Queso, Guacamole Love Cushion
US$9.90
The Gangsta
Slow-Braised Birria Beef, Mexican Rice, Roasted Corn, Queso and White Cheddar, Chipotle Serrano Crema, Cilantro, Tajin Lime
US$10.15
The Becky
Crispy Chicken, Mac N Cheese, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, A&R Spicy BBQ Jam, Crispy Tobacco Onions
US$10.15
The Easy Ranchero
French Fry Mix, Queso, Salsa, White Cheddar, Fried Egg, Cowboy Candy, Queso Cushion. Add Sweet & Spicy Bacon +1
US$9.00
The Smoke Show
BBQ Slathered Pulled Pork, Sweet Corn Fritters, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Queso, Crispy Tobacco Onions
US$10.15
The Snitch
Beer Battered Cod, Crushed Salt and Vinegar Chips, Tartar Slaw, Pickled Onions
US$10.15
The Boss Lady
Black Bean Fritters, Aged White Cheddar, Mexican Street Corn, Serrano Aioli, Crispy Carrots
US$9.00
The Bayou Baddie
Crispy Cajun Alligator, Tangy Cajun Remoulade, Shredded Lettuce, Diced Tomatoes, Diced Dill Pickles, Crispy Carrots
US$14.65
The Bee's Knees
Agave & Lime Chicken, Pico, Cowboy Candy, Crema
US$7.90
The Island Banger
Crisp Coconut Shrimp, Mango Pico, Sambal Crema, Thai Slaw, Lime
US$13.00
The Chipotle Chika
Honey Chipotle Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Tomato, Queso, White Cheddar, Sour Cream
US$9.00
The Yoda
Sweet & Spicy Chicken, Kung Pao Sauce, Peanuts, Egg Fried Rice, Spicy Crispy Carrots
US$9.90
The Hell Yeah
Crispy Chicken, Pimento Cheese Love Cushion, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Pineapple Slaw, Pickles, A&R BBQ, Salt & Vinegar Chips
US$10.15
The Alderman's Escort
Agave & Lime Chicken, Street Corn Salad, Cotija, Chile de Arbol
US$9.65
The Happy Meal
Seasoned Ground Beef, Fries, Dill Pickles, Comeback Sauce, Ketchup, White Cheddar, Queso Cushion.
US$9.65
The Love Shack
Seasoned Ground Beef, Fries, Dill Pickles, Comeback Sauce, Ketchup, White Cheddar, Queso Cushion
US$10.15
The BFF Of Karen
Fresh Avocado, Balsamic Mushrooms, Diced Tomatoes, Pickled Red Onions, Guacamole Cushion
US$9.00
The Cat's Meow
Andouille Sausage, Bourbon Shrimp, White Cheddar Grits, Green Onion, Jambalaya Sauce
US$11.25

Grilled Cheesy Street Tacos

Quesabirria Street Tacos
Braised Beef with Guajillo Chiles, Cheese, Cilantro, Onion, Dipping Consomé
US$21.45
Quesa Chicken Street Tacos
Agave & Lime Chicken, Sweeet & Spicy Bacon, Cheese, Onion, Dipping Consomé
US$19.20
Vegan Quesa Jackfruit Street Tacos
Jackfruit Carnitas, Agave BBQ, Charred Corn, Onion, Vegan Dipping Consomé
US$19.20
Quesa Pork Street Tacos
Pork Carnitas, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Melty Cheese, Dipping Consome
US$19.20
Quesa Vege Street Tacos
Shitake Mushrooms, Roasted Fresh Corn, Julienned Red Peppers & Onions, Melty Cheese, Chili Oil, Chipotle Crema Dipping Sauce
US$16.40

Not A Taco

Agave & Rye Chopped Salad
Crispy Chicken, Lettuce, Tomato, White Cheddar, Corn, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Black Beans, Peppercorn Buttermilk, A&R Spicy Chili & BBQ Jam, Tobacco Onions
US$17.80
Birria Grilled Burrito
Large Flour Tortilla filled with Slow-Braised Beef, Mexican Rice, Mozzarella, Queso, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Chipotle Crema, Birria Dipping Sauce
US$20.10
Crispy Chicken Burrito
Chopped Crispy Chicken, Mac N Cheese, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Queso, White Cheddar, Agave BBQ Jam, BBQ Ranch Dipping Sauce
US$16.90
Epic Burger
Two Smashed Burgers, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Queso Blanco, A&R BBQ, Shredded Lettuce, Tomato, Pickle, Potato Bun, French Fry Duo
US$18.05
Sister Of The Plain Jane Quesadilla
Large Flour Tortilla Stuffed with Seasoned Ground Beef, Mozzarella and Pepper Jack Cheeses, Sweet & Spicy Bacon, Mac N Cheese, Chipotle Crema. Served with Ranch and Chunky Salsa
US$16.90

Yum

Tiramisu Tres Leches Cake
Salty Caramel Sauce
US$8.50
Big Sis Layered Chocolate Cake
for 2
US$16.40
Big Sis Layered Carrot Cake
for 2
US$16.40

Cutlery and Napkins

Cutlery & Napkins
Cutlery & Napkins
US$0.00
Ready to order? Kerbside pickup, delivery and dine-in are all available. 📞 +1 812-993-8226